At the end of 2005, I had FICO scores that were somewhere in the 650-675 range. Mind you, I had no blemishes on my credit report. No lates, no collections, no nothing. So what was keeping my scores down? Utilization.
My utilization was out of hand. (For those who don't know, utilization is the amount of credit that you are currently using. If your credit limit is $5,000, and you're using $4,000 of that limit, then you're using 80% of your available credit. Thus, your utilization is 80%.) I knew that being nearly maxed out on some of my cards could be hurting my scores a bit, but I never realized that utilization was punishing me to such a large degree. Indeed, it wasn't unheard of for me to be 65% utilized across the board. After all, I figured that I could afford the debt service, so what was the problem? Turns out it was a big problem -- at least to creditors who peered at my credit report on a monthly basis.
My wake-up call arrived in early 2006 when Chase rate jacked me to the tune of 29.99%. This account was opened in 2000. I had never been late, never gone over the limit, and always paid more than the minimum. My reward? Rate jack! Thanks a lot, Chase. I immediately transferred the balance to a 0% card.
Curious, I decided to see if others had experienced the same kind of treatment from other creditors. I eventually Googled my way to a credit message board -- creditboards -- where people discuss all kinds of credit issues.
It was there that I discovered the deleterious effect that utilization was having on my scores. It also explained why Chase -- even though I had been a model customer (a very profitable customer, mind you) -- decided to up my interest to a loanshark-like 29.99%. Since then, I have been on a mission. I've added new credit cards to my stable -- and I've added many $100s of thousands in available credit.
What's more, my utilization has gone from the 64-65% range to 0%. As of today, I'm what the credit-card industry calls a "deadbeat." I don't carry balances. I pay all of my cards in full each month. I pay no interest. I utilize my cards for rewards and interest-free loans. That's it. These credit-card companies are giving me interest-free loans for up to 55 days (30 days during the statement period and 25 days during the grace period). I have finally turned the tables on the card companies. Card companies, it turns out, think that I am now a better risk, which is why I don't get turned down for new credit and now receive the best rates and generous limits.
My change in credit habits has allowed me to be free. I'll never be at the mercy of card companies that have you between a rock and a hard place. Remember, these card companies know your credit reports intimately (they conduct account reviews monthly). They know when you have access to other credit sources. Or don't.
Carrying balances from month to month puts you at the mercy of credit card companies. These credit card companies don't like you. They are not your friend. They don't care about you (miss a payment or go over your limit and you'll see). And they are not looking out for you. The only thing they care about is making a dollar off you. That's it. That's their business. Their goal is to exact as much coin from you as they possibly can.
Low utilization (I consider anything under 10% as low) also helps your credit scores. Utilization accounts for 30% of your credit score. My over-utilization was costing me about 100 points on my FICO score (FICO scores range from 300-850). FICO looks at utilization two ways. It looks at your overall utilization (all of your cards combined) and it looks at each card individually. Therefore, it's possible to get dinged for having one card maxed out while your overall utilization (on all of your cards) is relatively low. That's why you want to keep utilization down on individual cards, too.
Today, all of my scores are above 750. I haven't been under 700 since some time in early 2006. And I don't plan on returning anytime soon. 
Sunday, July 6, 2008
Utilization: What it is and why it Matters
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
BY EMAIL
RSS 


31 comments:
Oops, I meant CreditMattersBlog.com
We need an editor feature here. LOL!
Haha. I have an editor feature. I just kill the comment that my reader needed correcting on. You fixed it in a second comment, so I deleted the first comment.
Moving on, it's ironic that this is the most important thing I've written, and there were no comments. There were no comments, of course, because no one was reading my blog back then. I had few readers at that time of this column.
Next to paying your bills on time, this is the single most important category for FICO purposes. It's the one category where people can get TONS of points.
Maybe everyone already understands utilization? Maybe that's why there are not a lot of posts here. Ha!
Credit Matters:
So you deleted my first comment, now my "second" first comment don't mean squat!
LOL!
:-P
Well, we do know that it contained an error. Haha.
CM - I understand now the importance of low utilization but it made me think of something my father told me when I got my first credit card. He said that I should make a purchase (if my limit then was $200 I should charge $100) then make the minimum monthly payments each month until it is paid off and not pay it off in full right away. He said that way I show that I can make the monthly payments and it builds my credit history. Is that not true for todays financial environment? As someone who is working on re-building her credit rating does that make sense at all or should I stick with your plan - use cards to keep them active and then pay in full each month.
BTW...just saw the headlines on CNN.com. Seems that we ARE in a recession. Gee, ya think?
Sam, it's a myth that you need to carry balances so that you can show the lender that you can pay off your debt successfully over time. All it shows is that you can pay interest to the card company and make them rich.
I would argue that it's not smart to carry balances in this environment -- or the previous environment.
Even if you pay in full each month, your balance (when the statement is closed) will be reported to the credit bureaus. You'll build a credit history by paying in full each month. That's my point.
Sam, read this story on paying in full.
I think you'll appreciate it.
http://www.creditmattersblog.com/2008/10/paying-in-full-is-not-only-good-for.html
CM - Ok, good article. Makes sense about paying in full makes you more careful about what you buy. Ok, I keep working on paying down my balances ($3,000 more to go!) and then pay in full each month. When I look at the amount of interest I have paid over the years it makes me sick.
Sam, all I can say is that my choice to pay in full has never hurt my ability to get new credit. If anything, it has only helped.
There is simply no reason to pay interest to the credit card companies. Ever.
If you have a choice, pay in full. If you must carry a balance, find a low-interest card to do it.
CM - Once I pay off my current cards I'm really going to stick with paying in full each month. I really don't want to get into the habit of carrying balances again. Plus, I can't think of anything I need or want that would require a large sum of money that I couldn't save up for. I'm looking forward to the day when I too will be a credit card companies "bad customer". :)
Sam, once you start paying in full, you'll really beat yourself up. You'll realize how easy it is to save money, you'll realize just how much you've been paying in interest, and you realize that you bought a lot of things that you really didn't need.
But that's OK. You won't be doing that any longer.
When you finally get to the point where you are paying in full, please come back and leave me a note. Let me know what you think of the pay-in-full lifestyle.
CM - I will definatly leave you a message when I'm all paid in full. I'm hoping that will be by April 2009 or shortly thereafter. I have some large expenses coming up such as the taxes on my car and I'm moving in April so that will cost some. But I'm moving into a townhouse that will cost me about $350 a month less. So even more savings there.
So, unless something catastrophic happens 2009 should be a good year!
Sam, glad to hear. Looking forward to seeing you succeed at this game.
Hi there again! This is John. I just posted a comment a few moments ago on another of your articles (they guy with the IDtheft, rebuilding his credit...) Quick question for you -- I susbscribe to MYFICO and my three scores are in the mid to upper 600s (650, 647, and 687). As I said earlier, I was granted a discharge 2 and half years ago, but on all three reports, MYFICO shows some 57 accounts as being "late" and being facotred into my utilization, even though they are all closed. Any thoughts?? Thanks again! John
You're getting out of my area of expertise, John.
But those accounts, if coded correctly, should not be factored into your utilization. Those accounts were discharged and should be at $0 balances. I'd likely be disputing those as inaccurate. Have you pulled your credit report lately? How are those being reported? Are they actually showing balances?
I understand the lates, though. Before your discharge, I take it that you were late. Those won't be removed just because you went BK.
They are indeed at 0. Some even say 'paying or paid as agreed'. At the time of my BK, I was advised by my atty to not pay anything, even though I wanted to becasue prior, my repayment history was perfect. Oh well, can't dwell on the past, I suppose. Right now I am focussing on my LSAT. Thanks, John
Interesting on the utilization, then. Doesn't make sense.
Anyhow, good luck on the LSAT.
Hi Marcus--could not find the correct article to reply to, but given that my comment is related to utilization I thought I'd share some good news. Thanks to you (the article escapes me, though) I rceived my Nordy VISA. I called the live CSR Center as you suggested (not automated tel no) and very politely said the purpose of my call is two-fold: 1st to open, 2nd to seek a CLI--Even though I was told I would have to wait 7 months initially, thanks to one of your articles, I told the rep that I was concerned about utilization, my FICO in general, and that I wanted their card to to take the place of another card I use. I was stunned when the rep said, 'what would you like?" Although I wanted to ask for 5k, I didn't want to blow my chances at a possible CLI, so I asked for 1,500.00 She placed me on hold and in about 15 seconds came back and said ok, no problem. I was excited and confused at the same time (initially a supervisor said only $500.00, then wait 7 months). Yet, this CSr said ok. Wonder if I should have asked for more? She also said they they keep close tabs on credit reports and that customers become eligible for a CLI every four months (without a hard pull, as you said). Anyway, just wanted t thanks you again. You have been more helpful than my BK atty was a couple of years ago and I appreciate your blog very much. By chance, are you hoping to becom a BK Atty? Best--Jon
Jon, I do not have any plans to be a BK attorney, even though I did just take a bankruptcy class in law school. Final exam was this past week. I actually enjoyed the material very much. But I don't have any plans to practice in that area. I could see myself doing some BKs for friends (or friends of friends), though.
As for Nordstrom, you should have asked for $5,000. It would not have hurt. If they could not accommodate your request, they likely would have countered. Indeed, I would have said this: Yes, I'd like $5,000 -- but if you can't do that, I'll take whatever you can grant me.
At this point, don't worry about it. Just use the card and make sure your payments are always made on time. Several months from now, you'll call in and ask for a CLI. They'll see that you are a great customer and you'll get the CLI.
And that will be that.
I'm glad that my blog could be a small part of your success.
Thanks for sharing.
Nice explanation about the utilization. Dave Ramsey is a deadbeat also as his FICO score is the same as yours "zero"!! WTG!
In essence then I shouldn't worry about opting out of these companies that want to raise my APRs like Citi does by Jan. 31? I was told my other credit card companies would see this and close my credit cards too. We have over $100K of credit lines and that would disappear. Debt to ratio would be non-existent. Credit scores would be trashed until we PIF everyone we owe. I don't want to pay the higher interest either. I'm retired now and securing more cards now would be like trying to get more health or life insurance with a preexisting condition!!!
I just don't know what to do these days. CiifIcare
CifIcare, Dave Ramsey's score is 0. Mine is not 0.
You likely don't need more cards, Anon.
And people can, and should, opt out when the new APR will create a payment that can't be paid.
Was just thinking about it. Dave Ramsey doesn't have a score. The lowest score is 300 -- not 0. So, I misspoke when I said that Ramsey's score was 0. He simply doesn't have a score.
Okay...I think I should give my credit brains a rest! LOL
CiifIcare
CifIcare, we can all use a rest. Haha. You and I could have done a tag-team presentation there.
If utilization is 30% and credit scores go up to 850, does that mean going from maxed out credit cards to paid off balances gives you 30% of 850 = 255 points? That seems like too much, but how else would it work?
Nope. Because the score range is from 300-850. That means that utilization is worth 165 points max. That's 30% of 550 points equals 165.
Thanks for the clarification, that makes more sense.
Do you know if maxed credit cards to no balance gives us that entire 165 points? I've heard elsewhere estimates of 1 point per percent, which would mean only 100 points.
Tom, I wish it was as simple as that. There are breaks all along the way (30%, 50%, 60%, etc.).
Just as a reference point, FICO High Achievers, on average, have 7% utilization. A FICO High Achiever is defined as a person who has a score of 760 or above.
Personally, my sweet spot seems to be 1% utilization. I get the biggest bang for my buck at 1% utilization. Also, I tend to get dinged if I report 0% utilization. I lose 5 to 10 points for not having any of my credit cards report a balance to the credit reporting agencies.
If you are interested in FICO High Achievers, you can read my story here:
http://www.creditmattersblog.com/2008/08/want-to-be-fico-high-achiever-do-what.html
I just need to say thanks to CM and everyone here. I posted last month how I was just learning about utilization and building credit. Naively thinking I was doing okay as long as a paid in full Each Month.
Then I found out my scores were in the 640-670 range. I'm happy to say now that I understand utilization and brought it down to 1-2 percent before posting my score jumped 55 points.
Thanks Again.
Jay, woohoo. Congrats. Glad to see that you are doing well.
Utilization is one of those things that I consider low-hanging fruit. If you can get it down, it's easy to pick up points.
agree with your comments. there was a time before the credit card companies got smart that you could get multiple lines of credit or cash advances at 0% for 6 months with little or no fee. at one time i had 150,000 in an ing account paying about 3-4 % interest. each month i would see what was coming due and pay it off all the while earning interest free less tax. of course you needed to be disciplined about the whole thing. nowadays that avenue has been pretty much been stripped away since most cc companies want 3% cash advance fee. There are some things i still do like applying for an amazon card and getting a 50 credit off my first purchase. I used to be concerned about applying for too many cards but if you use it once to get a discount (i.e. amex will give 100 bucks off some tickets occasionally) then just throw it away and wait for the next promotion. Periodically i will do the 0% transfer but only if it's free, and if they give you a cash advance check.
Post a Comment